Politics of Energy Trilemma in the Contemporary World. Where is the Truth?

Jacob Dut Chol Riak

Abstract

Energy access continues to lead to conundrums in many forms. One of such conundrums is the endless competition and imbalance of politics, economics, and environment, which form trilemma of energy policy and which hinder energy access and deepen energy poverty. This study argues that energy trilemma can be resolved through energy good governance. Energy good governance provokes debates on both neoliberal and conservative discourses on energy access and efficiency. It argues that equality, rule of law; respect for human rights, accountability and transparency should form the quintet of Energy Good Governance (EGG). To clearly comprehend the EGG, the study appraises the applicability and the implementation of the equality, rule of law, respect for human rights, accountability and transparency in energy projects in South Sudan, East African Community and European Union. Moreover, the study assesses the national energy polices of South Sudan, regional, and global energy policies.


While the study in detail evaluates the energy access and poverty, it critically analyses the 2015 Paris Agreement, particularly on its impact on national, regional and international level energy trilemma. Although energy access remains a problem as its impacts energy poverty and halt energy transition, energy access can be improved through EGG policy and in particular, through deepening economic development energy policies for South Sudan and the region. The study deploys case study of South Sudan, EAC and European Union in understanding the conundrums of energy access. The study also analyzes the impact of Russia-Ukraine war on global access to energy. It uses process tracing in deepening the comprehension of the casual chains and casual mechanisms in energy trilemma paradox. While the study concludes the importance of energy good governance as the true way of resolving energy trillemma, it recommends further studies on impact of energy good governance on energy transition in East Africa.

References

1. Ayuk, NJ. (2022). A Just Transition: Making Energy Poverty History with Natural Resources. Made for Success Publishing.
2. Barigaba, J. (2021). Cost of Hoima-Tanga Pipeline Hits $5B. The East African Magazine, Nairobi.
3. Bhatia, M and Angelou, N. (2015). Beyond Connection: Energy Access Defined. Energy Sector Management Assistance Programs, World Bank.
4. Chol, J. (2016). The Reality of Petroleum Resource Curse in South Sudan: Can this be avoided? African Review Journal, Vol 43 (2): 17-50
5. Deng, J. (2022). Privatization and Deregulation of Electricity Sector in South Sudan. International Journal of Strategic Energy and Environmental Planning. Vol 4 (1): 18-34
6. Frank, M. (2008). European Council and Energy Draft Policy: A critical Review. Belgrade Publishers.
7. Gatluak, D. (2024). Challenges of Electricity Access in South Sudan. Universal Printers
8. George, A and Bennet, A. (2015). Case Studies and Theory Development in Social Sciences. MIT Press.
9. Hailu, Y. (2017). EAC Energy Security Framework. EAC News Magazine, Arusha.
10. Heffron, R eta al. (2015). Resolving Society’s Energy Trilemma through the Energy Justice Metric. Energy Policy. Vol 87 (1): 168-176
11. Held, D. (2008). Energy Consumption and Production: EU 27 Energy Dependence Rate. EU Printers.
12. International Energy Agency, Report, 2019.
13. Metsola, A. (2016). Regional Integration and Role of EU In Economic Development. Macmillan
14. Mozersky, D and Kammen, D. (2024). South Sudan’s Renewable Energy Potential: A Building Block for Peace. USIP.
15. Nalule, V. (2019). Energy Poverty and Access Challenges in Sub-Saharan Africa: The Role of Regionalism. Palgrave Macmillan
16. Pippidi, A and Johnston, M. (2017). Transition to Democracy and Good Governance. Bloomberg Publishers.
17. Quinn, R and Dawson, L. (2019). Good Governance is a Choice: A way to Re-create the Board the Right Way. Edward Elgar Publishers
18. Setyowati, A. (2020). Mitigating Energy Poverty: Mobilizing Climate Finance to Manage the Energy Trilemma in Indonesia. Sustainability-MDPI.
19. World Bank Report, (2022). Global Energy Report. Washington, DC

Authors

Jacob Dut Chol Riak
[1]
“Politics of Energy Trilemma in the Contemporary World. Where is the Truth?”, Soc. sci. humanities j., vol. 8, no. 12, pp. 5994–6002, Dec. 2024, doi: 10.18535/sshj.v8i12.1500.